Dear Fellow Comic Book Fans;
My name is Mychal Clements and I have been reading comics for a little over a year. When I first got into comics I was excited and bought a broad range of different titles and different artists.
I quickly learned that not everything on the shelves was good quality and quickly retreated into my shell and only bought the books that I knew were good. Or reviews told me were good.
However this summer there were many weeks when only one or two books that I was following came out at a time. Because I don’t carry cash on me, I needed to by more books in order to meet the ten dollar requirement for a debit card transaction.
Because of this I began to try more books, on Wednesday’s I would walk around the table debating what looked good. I often times found that the covers of some books caught my eye and I went home with a few surprises. I began to branch out from my little DC world and taste some of what marvel was doing. I even went so far as too begin to collect some Image titles.
I am a college student and I have two professors that both read comics and are nerds like myself. I was excited when I learned this, and quickly grilled them on their knowledge and thoughts on some of my favorite characters.
I was happy that I had some older comic fans to converse with, however I learned a distressing truth. When I talked about DC or Marvel characters, they knew copious amounts of facts and history. But when I mentioned the Image titles I had become excited about over the summer, they looked at me like I was crazy.
Based on conversations with fans like this and several other comic fans in stores I have discovered a dreadful truth. My fellow comic fans are a jade bunch, you have have been abused by some publishers and treated like you were children.
I sympathize with you, however I feel that you have made an error in your reaction. You have retreated into your shell and limited your comic intake to the few titles that you have been reading for years. And you are reading the same stories over and over again.
I beg you, please try new books. It is an obvious truth that the comic industry is struggling, and what it needs is for comic readers to try new books. You won’t know a book is bad unless you read it.
Give as many books as you can at least 1 issue. And if you didn’t like it write a letter to the publisher saying why you didn’t like it. Not a personal attack, but a critique. Write and say what you would like to see in the book. Phrases like “This book is garbage” is not what I’m talking about. And on the other side of that if you liked a book write the publisher or the creator and tell them what you liked about it. The comic industry needs more mature and thoughtful feedback on more of the content. And that can only happen if we as a community of consumers grow up and try new things, and talk about it like adults.
Thank you,
Myke Clements
Jamie Langenbrunner
November 17, 2010
Shut the fuck up!
tmyke
November 18, 2010
Well thank you for that very mature response.
Corey Blake
November 18, 2010
Heartily agreed. What kind of comics have you discovered once you started branching out? I’ve gone from just reading Marvel superheroes (some I still love) to reading from publishers like Fantagraphics, Drawn & Quarterly, First Second, Boom!, Archaia, IDW, Image, Vertigo/DC, and some self-published and webcomics. I’m trying to stretch out into manga as well (loved The Color trilogy, although it’s technically manhwa/Korean comics).
tmyke
November 19, 2010
Well I’ve discovered Robert Kirkman, and I am completely caught up on Invincible, that was an awesome week and a half. And I’m halfway caught up on The Walking Dead. And I’ve recently started following haunt. I’ve found some cool Allan Moore books, like “Supreme” and I’m about 4 volumes into “Y the last man” and my current favorite is Chew
jephd
November 18, 2010
STFU N00B. The publishers should Publish only good stuff like when i was 15. DC sux and Marvel Rulez and all these Crappy N00Bee Publishers should STFU except for when they do cool things like show things blowing up and boobies…….. etc.
Welcome to the family Myke.
tmyke
November 18, 2010
Jephd, there is a flaw with your statement that “publishers should publish only good stuff” the problem with what your statement is that the publisher think and feel that what they are publishing IS good. We all know that not everything ever published is good, but the publishers don’t necessarily know.
Which if would have comprehended my letter you would have noticed that I asked that my fellow fans write to the publishers and maturely tell them what they like and what they don’t like.
Furthermore after talking with the owner of the shop I go to, comic fans also need to have dialog with the owners to see whats good and try new things. This attitude of rejection of the independent and new publishers, as well as your apparent hatred for DC is the very thing that I wish was different.
You sir are closed off to potentially entertaining and worthwhile purchases. I pity you.
Jase
November 18, 2010
Honestly, I got the impression he was being sarcastic, Mike. Or at least that’s how he came off to me.
Tom
November 18, 2010
I think Myke is the only one here that’s not brainwashed on all the usual crap that Marvel and DC put out except for some exceptions. Some children shouldn’t be left unsupervised (Jamie & Jeph). If you want boobies & stuff blowing up just watch some porn and 80′s action movies. You probably think that Steven Segal is a great actor dumbass.Most of the best comics come from the independent publishers because I’ve been reading comics since the friggin’ 70′s so I’m not a noob. I love the Walking Dead and Invincible from Image Comics. Garth Ennis’ The Boys kicks ass too. He rarely disappoints. There’s also a few titles from Avatar comics that I absolutely love so both of you can shut the hell up if you can’t have any constructive criticism.
tmyke
November 18, 2010
Thank you Tom.
Jase
November 18, 2010
I appreciate the intent of this letter, though I’m doubtful many will take any of it to heart.
prolix42
November 18, 2010
Many things go into what comics I choose each month (and yes, I collect some books ALWAYS), but my guiding principle is to see who wrote it and then to thumb the book and see if I can stand the art. The artist doesn’t have to be great, just bearable to me. On a side note, to take a stand against any one company seems silly too.
Nathan K
November 22, 2010
I completely agree with this! I was exactly the same way.
Бојан М. Ђукић
November 24, 2010
What needs to be considered is also the glorious past of American comics in newspaper syndication form. What we have nowadays wouldn’t happen without the incomparable legacies of Alex Raymond, Harold Foster, Al Williamson, Leonard Starr, Dan Barry and so many others. Even comicbook medium had publishers beyond Marvel/Atlas/Timely or National/DC and artists beyond Jack Kirby. Find out the Joe Maneely treasures or Lou Fine, Jack Cole…
… and THEN there are Europeans..! And South Americans..! And Asians – not only Japanese..!
A lifetime of joy and wonder await every dedicated and committed comics fan. In America fans may have called themselves nerds, in Europe top-notch intellectuals are connoscieurs of the medium and most dedicated fans.
Thanks for the inspiring ‘call to arms’. Comics shall prevail as long as we love and respect them.
BOJAN M. DJUKICH
ptrain
November 30, 2010
There are so many errors in this post. Not factual, but technical. It’s disappointing to read the sentence, “I often times the covers of some books got me and I went home with a few surprises.” If you are going to be publishing written works, you could at least take the time to proofread your work. It not only shows that you care about your reader, but also that you care about what you are writing.